Newcastle 2-3 Everton: Premier League Upset Recap at St James' Park

Everton produced a dramatic upset at St James' Park as they beat Newcastle United 3-2 on Saturday, leaving Eddie Howe’s side further adrift in the Premier League race for European places. Goals from Jarrad Branthwaite (19'), Beto (34') and a decisive Thierno Barry strike (83') overturned Jacob Ramsey’s deflected opener (32') and Jacob Murphy’s late reply (82') for Newcastle in a contest that underlined Newcastle’s recent wobble and Everton’s resilience under David Moyes.

Match Recap: Newcastle 2-3 Everton

The scoring began when James Garner’s inswinging corner met the head of Jarrad Branthwaite in the 19th minute, with the Everton centre-back directing the ball via the inside of the post past Nick Pope to make it 1-0. Newcastle responded through Jacob Ramsey in the 32nd minute after Sandro Tonali’s defence-splitting pass found Ramsey; his shot took a deflection and looped over Jordan Pickford to level the match. Just 105 seconds later, Dwight McNeil’s long-range effort was spilled by Nick Pope and Beto was on hand to smash home the rebound and restore Everton’s lead (34'). The game remained 2-1 at half-time, and after Jacob Murphy pulled Newcastle back to 2-2 in the 82nd minute, Thierno Barry produced what Sky described as a "scruffy" winner a minute later to seal a 3-2 victory for Everton.

Key Moments and Goals

Everton’s opener owed everything to set-piece execution: James Garner’s corner and Jarrad Branthwaite’s near-post finish in the 19th minute. The second goal sequence epitomised the match’s momentum swings—Sandro Tonali’s through-ball to Jacob Ramsey in the 32nd minute produced a deflected equaliser, but Everton struck immediately when Dwight McNeil’s effort was spilled by Pope, allowing Beto to make it 2-1 in the 34th minute. Newcastle’s Jacob Murphy made it 2-2 in the 82nd, but Thierno Barry’s follow-up in the 83rd minute—after Everton had been forced to change their starting plan with Beto preferred to Thierno Barry—proved decisive.

Tactical Analysis

Eddie Howe made multiple changes after his side’s midweek European fixtures, restoring six players to the starting XI including Anthony Gordon, Nick Pope, Lewis Hall, Malick Thiaw, Jacob Ramsey and Anthony Elanga following the Champions League schedule that saw Newcastle prevail in two legs against Qarabağ (6-1 away, 3-2 home in the return leg). Those rotation choices left Newcastle looking sluggish early on; they invited pressure which led to Branthwaite’s header from a James Garner corner. David Moyes, who made four changes after Everton’s 0-1 defeat to Manchester United on Monday Night Football, set his side up to be opportunistic on the break—Dwight McNeil’s long-range work and Garner’s delivery from set-pieces were decisive. Newcastle’s midfield creativity, briefly restored by Sandro Tonali’s defence-splitting pass for Ramsey’s equaliser, was not sustained for long enough to overcome Everton’s clinical moments.

Newcastle and Everton Notes

• Newcastle United: Eddie Howe’s side had returned several starters after the Champions League games, but have now won just once in their last seven Premier League matches and were left to rue missed control at St James’ Park. Club medical updates before the game indicated hopes that Jacob Ramsey might train and that Tino Livramento could be available in early March, while Lewis Miley’s recovery remained cautious.
• Everton: David Moyes’ men responded well to their recent 0-1 defeat to Manchester United, with Beto and Thierno Barry both on target—the former restoring the lead and the latter scoring the winner. Everton’s win moved them back into contention for a top-half finish after a mixed run of form away from home.
• Missing players: Everton were without Charly Alcaraz and goalkeeper Mark Travers through injury, forcing Moyes to rely on Jordan Pickford and defensive options like Branthwaite to deliver on the road.

Implications for the Table

Before kick-off, Newcastle occupied 11th place with 36 points after their European midweek commitments, and the defeat at St James’ Park means Eddie Howe’s side have lost ground in the battle for European qualification. Everton entered the match with 37 points and in ninth place, and the three points at Newcastle saw David Moyes’ side climb back into the top eight, restoring momentum after their loss to Manchester United. Newcastle’s single win in seven Premier League matches is now a worrying trend for a team balancing domestic and continental demands.

Player Performance and Management

Jarrad Branthwaite’s 19th-minute header highlighted Everton’s aerial threat, while Beto’s 34th-minute finish underlined Moyes’ gamble in starting him over Thierno Barry—only for Barry to come on and score the winner in the 83rd minute. Jacob Ramsey, restored to the XI by Howe, scored a deflected goal in the 32nd minute after Sandro Tonali’s incisive pass; Ramsey’s return to fitness had been monitored in the run-up to the game. Nick Pope, reinstated in goal for Newcastle after midweek rotation, was culpable for the loose moment that allowed Beto to score, and could be a focal point for post-match review by Howe. Everton’s James Garner continued his impressive season by providing the corner that led to Branthwaite’s opener.

Recap and Outlook

This match will be remembered for its rapid momentum changes and Everton’s clinical response to Newcastle’s brief spells of control. Newcastle’s Champions League commitments—two wins over Qarabağ (6-1 and 3-2) that secured a last-16 tie with Barcelona—have clearly stretched the squad, and Howe must now address a run in which the Magpies have managed only one Premier League win in seven games. David Moyes will take confidence from the victory: after the 0-1 loss to Manchester United, his team showed resilience on the road and now occupy a higher spot in the table following the win at St James’ Park.

For more Premier League recaps and similar match-day drama, see our coverage of other high-scoring fixtures like Burnley 3-4 Brentford — Premier League Thriller Recap and Liverpool 5-2 West Ham: Premier League Recap & Analysis.

ScorePoint AI provides data-driven AI predictions and a live AI assistant to help fans and bettors analyse matches like Newcastle vs Everton; our models factor in squad rotation, recent form, and match-specific events for in-depth recap and analysis.

Next up, Newcastle must regroup domestically while managing a demanding European schedule and lingering fitness concerns for players such as Tino Livramento and Lewis Miley; Everton will look to build on this 3-2 win as they chase a top-half finish. The result at St James’ Park is a timely reminder that Premier League momentum can shift quickly—Everton seized their moment, and Newcastle must now find answers to arrest a troubling domestic run.